Blog Layout

What Is Driving Inflated Rent Amounts on Zillow?

What does Zillow say your rental property should be renting for? 


Zillow is a pretty popular site for tenants to find homes and for owners and landlords to list them. For marketing purposes, it’s a great site. For the purposes of pricing your rental home, however, you might want to use more reliable data. 


A lot of rental property owners feel somewhat misled by the rental estimates they find on Zillow. These “Zestimates” have been inflated recently, and it underscores the importance of accessing good data when you’re pricing your rental home. Don’t rely only on what you find on general rental sites like Zillow and others. 


What’s driving these inflated rental amounts?


We did some investigating. 


Estimates and Data for Sacramento Rentals 


The first problem may be faulty or incomplete data. Remember that estimates are only as good as the information that’s provided to the algorithm making the estimate. Zillow has access to very generalized numbers. It’s going to be a more macro look rather than a nuanced dissection of a local zip code or neighborhood


There’s also the matter of accuracy. Zillow may not have correct information about the homes that are listed on their site. That’s going to lead to potentially higher estimates. If a Zestimate says that your home could potentially rent for $2,500 a month, that could be due to the fact that they think you have more square footage than you do. Or, you’re listed as a three-bedroom when your home only has two. 


Zillow's Zestimate relies heavily on publicly available data, and this means that it may not take into account certain factors that are likely to impact actual pricing. 


Market Conditions and Zillow’s Estimates 


Zillow also has less of an ability to factor in the current market conditions when they’re attaching rental estimates to properties. When pricing properties, seasons have an impact. The availability of inventory, too. Mortgage rates in the sales market will impact the rental market and the rents that owners are charging for their homes. 


There’s less agility in a system such as Zillow, making it more difficult for them to make rental estimates with accuracy. This can lead to inflated estimates. 


Pricing Your Sacramento Rental Property Accurately 

pricing your rent

We always tell landlords, owners, real estate investors, and even tenants to be careful about following what they find on Zillow and sites like it. The data we collect as local property managers is far more reliable, and it also takes into consideration the unique features of your property, the nuances of your neighborhood, and the market conditions that may change the average rental value of a home overnight. 


Work with a property manager before you price your property. If you rely solely on Zillow and similar rental sites, you may be pricing your home too high. That’s going to leave you with a longer vacancy and higher costs throughout the marketing and leasing period. 


Let’s talk about what your rental home is really worth. We invite you to contact us at Sacramento Delta Property Management. We’ve been working with owners and investors for more than 40 years. 



Should You Advertise to SHRA Voucher Holders Only? Why or Why Not?
By Sandy Highland February 20, 2025
Finding qualified residents quickly is your primary goal, and while SHRA offers valuable resources, it’s important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of limiting your marketing scope.
Why Can’t My Tenants Just Pay the Water Bill (or HOA Bill) Directly? - Article Banne
By Sandy Highland February 6, 2025
Why Can’t My Tenants Just Pay the Water Bill (or HOA Bill) Directly?
Which Income Bracket Are Most Renters In? - Article Banner
By Sandy Highland January 23, 2025
Have you ever wondered about the income of the average tenant in Sacramento? We have some data to share about what people are earning and why they’re renting.
Who Do I Contact to See If I Can Afford to Be a Landlord - Article Banner
By Sandy Highland January 9, 2025
When potential landlords contact us at Sacramento Delta Property Management, these are the things we tell them about as we’re exploring whether they’re financially ready to be a landlord.
Tips for Efficiently Managing Multiple Properties - Article Banner
By Sandy Highland November 21, 2024
These are just some of the things that need to happen when you are efficiently managing multiple properties.
Strategies for Dealing with Difficult Tenants in Sacramento Rentals
By Sandy Highland November 7, 2024
Those difficult tenants come in all shapes, sizes, and mannerisms. Understanding how to effectively manage such people and situations is crucial.
Emerging Neighborhoods in Sacramento: Where to Invest Next - Article Banner
By Sandy Highland October 24, 2024
Here are some of the emerging neighborhoods in Sacramento that you don’t want to miss.
Investing in Green Technology for Rental Properties: Costs and Benefits - Article Banner
By Sandy Highland October 10, 2024
Real estate investors have an opportunity to invest in green technology and make their rental properties more appealing, efficient, and cost-effective.
Exploring the Impact of Interest Rate Changes on Sacramento's Rental Market - Article Banner
By Sandy Highland September 26, 2024
In this blog post, we’ll explore how interest rate changes impact Sacramento's rental market, and what investors should consider in the coming months.
Navigating Tenant Laws in Sacramento: An Investor's Guide - Article Banner
By Sandy Highland September 12, 2024
Let’s take a look at the best way to navigate tenant laws in Sacramento to ensure you remain in compliance.
More Posts
Share by: